California voters killed the billionaire tax, but a leading tax scholar says the next fight will not target net worth at all. It targets what happens when wealth changes hands. For family offices, the battlefield just moved from the balance sheet to the will.
The hook: the victory lap is premature
California’s one time 5 percent tax on billionaire wealth, Proposition 40, went down roughly 53 to 47, The Times of India recapped on 16 November. Champagne in the family office? Not so fast. The same day, WBUR’s Here and Now interviewed Boston College professor Ray Madoff, author of The Second Estate, and her map of what comes next should make every succession planner sit up.
The detective reveal: the target is the handoff
Madoff’s argument is simple and spicy. Wealth taxes face two walls. States cannot stop residents from moving, and at the federal level she believes the current Supreme Court would quite likely find a wealth tax unconstitutional. So the smart money in policy is not on taxing net worth. It is on widening the income tax to catch investment gains and inheritances the way it already catches wages.
Her clue is a number. She told WBUR that while the richest 1 percent owned over $50 trillion in 2025, estate and gift taxes raised only $28 billion. She also noted that a $100 million gift does not even need reporting as income today, while $100 found on the street technically does. With Democrats set to regain power in Congress next year, per the interview, that gap is exactly the kind of headline lawmakers love.
Translation for dynasties: the risk is no longer an annual bill on what you own. It is a toll at the exact moment wealth passes to the next generation.
The pivot: time is the truly scarce asset
Rules that hit transfers reward families who planned before the rules landed. Documented cost bases, clear governance and succession structures settled while the code is still friendly are the moat. Waiting for a final bill means planning on someone else’s clock.
See where trophy wealth is parked on Luxury Power Lists, and collectible assets built to be inherited on Limited Editions Europe.
Family offices and principals
Reviewing a succession plan, a trust structure or a second base before the next tax cycle? Our single confidential desk is here: Apply for Private Review.
FAQ
Did California pass the billionaire tax?
No. Proposition 40 was rejected by roughly 53 percent to 47 percent.
What does Ray Madoff expect next?
Efforts to bring investment income and inheritances into the income tax system.
Why not a federal wealth tax?
Madoff believes the current Supreme Court would quite likely rule it unconstitutional.