California killed its billionaire tax, Washington kept its millionaire levy, and rich families are itching to act. Advisors quoted by InvestmentNews say the costliest move is selling early. The hidden risk is not the tax. It is the cash squeeze.
The hook: the tax lost, the anxiety did not
California’s Proposition 40 failed 52.8% to 47.2%, and its union backers have vowed to return in 2028. A week earlier, Washington voters refused to repeal the state’s new 9.9% tax on income above $1 million, which is on track for 2028 pending a constitutional challenge. InvestmentNews laid out the split on 18 November, and the advisors it spoke to agreed on one thing: do not restructure around a bill nobody has read.
The detective reveal: selling early can cost more than the tax
Here is the trap. Kylie Allen of 49 Financial’s Fractional Family Office told InvestmentNews that dumping a low basis stock or property locks in capital gains tax today to dodge a tax that may never exist. Worse, a sale gives up the step-up in basis at death, the rule that resets an inherited asset to market value and can wipe out decades of embedded gains for heirs.
So where is the real exposure? Liquidity. Allen’s example: if 70 to 80% of a net worth sits in one private company or a few illiquid positions, a wealth tax just makes the cash squeeze obvious. Her hardest case is the founder who owes a bill on value that cannot easily become cash. She warns that valuation disputes are where these taxes get ugly, so clean, current appraisals matter.
Movement is already happening. Jim Claypool of Coldstream Wealth Management said migration is under way in Washington, where Bloomberg Tax reported the levy would affect roughly 30,000 people. Allen adds a warning: keeping the house, the doctors and the social life while claiming a new address is a common way to lose an audit.
The pivot: optionality is the scarce asset
Laws change on a ballot. A family’s reaction time does not change unless it is built in advance. Current appraisals, a funded liquidity plan and estate documents that work with or without a wealth tax are the quiet edge. As Allen put it, a plan on paper costs nothing.
See how rich lists shift when tax maps move on Luxury Power Lists, and read how founders turn their stories into lasting assets on USA Publication House.
Family offices and principals
Reviewing liquidity, valuations or residency ahead of the next ballot cycle? Principals can reach one confidential desk only: Apply for Private Review.
FAQ
Did California pass its billionaire tax?
No. Proposition 40 failed 52.8% to 47.2%, though backers plan to try again in 2028.
Why not sell assets before a wealth tax arrives?
Advisors say it locks in capital gains now and gives up the step-up in basis at death.
What should families review instead?
Concentration, liquidity, current appraisals and estate documents.